Ashford University Five Basic Elements of Persuasion Discussion
What does it mean to critique an analysis? The following questions are not a mechanical set of questions to be followed. Rather they are guides for you to consider as you write a coherent reflective essay:
Do you find the approach, evidence, and analysis persuasive, engaging, and helpful? Do you it effectively portrays the health issue?
Are the sources used reasonable, up-to-date, and appropriate?
- Does the analysis fully cover the issue, or does it miss something significant?
- Is the format of the analysis effective, and accessible to readers?
- Are the graphics (tables, charts, photographs, maps, etc.) connected to the text? Do they have a narrative of their own that works with the text?
- Are the graphics legible, and do they aid in the argument or narrative?
- What are the main strengths of the analysis, and what are its weaknesses?
- Please recognize, I am not looking for a set of bullet points or sentence fragments. I expect you to write a critique, not jot down a few notes. My suggestion is, consider the two-four strongest aspects of the project, the most significant areas for improvement, and some general thoughts on the form and content. The critique should have an introductory paragraph and a conclusion framing these thoughts.
